Free consultation · No fee unless we win · I come to you

Call or text (864) 777-1000
Animals in the road · Abbeville County, SC

Cow, Horse or Dog in the Road in Abbeville County: Who Pays for the Wreck

If someone's cow, horse or dog was in the road, the owner may have to pay, whether you were driving or riding as a passenger. I'll drive out to you. Riding in a car that hit a deer? If the driver was careless, the driver's coverage may still pay you.

Before you need any of this: print the free South Carolina accident checklist and keep it in your glovebox.

After an Abbeville County wreck with an animal in the road, the first question is whose animal it was. If you hit a wild animal while driving, your own coverage usually comes first; my single-vehicle crash guide walks through it. If it was someone's cow, horse, goat, hog or dog, this page is for you, whether you hit it, swerved to miss it or rode as a passenger. The same goes if a driver swerved for any animal and hit you. Wherever it happened, on SC-72, SC-28, SC-20, Highway 71 or a county road, call or text (864) 777-1000.

"Animal In Road": Listed About Once for Every Four Abbeville County Collisions in 2024

"Animal In Road" was listed as a contributing factor 74 times on Abbeville County's 301 reported collisions in 2024, about once for every four, according to the county's page in the state Department of Public Safety's 2024 Traffic Collision Fact Book. It was the second most-listed factor on that page. The Fact Book notes that officers can enter up to five contributing factors on one report, so the 74 counts how often the factor was listed, not wrecks an animal caused.

Of the Fact Book's 46 county summaries, only Allendale County's listed it at a higher rate. On the Fact Book's Greenwood and Anderson county pages, it was listed about once for every 14 or 15 collisions. My rural-roads post explains why the same crash is worse on a rural road.

Statewide, the Fact Book counts far more collisions with deer than with all other animals combined. The county page does not say which animals those 74 listings were. For your claim, that is exactly what matters.

Deer, Wild Hog or Somebody's Cow: Whose Animal Was It?

Wild animals. A deer usually leaves no one to claim against, so if you hit one while driving, your claim generally goes to your own coverage. A passenger is different: if the driver was careless, the driver's coverage may pay.

The hog in between. The 2024 harvest table from the state Department of Natural Resources (SCDNR) ranks Abbeville first of 46 counties for wild hogs taken by deer hunters: an estimated 6.4 per square mile of deer habitat, against 1.7 statewide. That table measures what hunters took, not how many hogs live in the county. SCDNR also traces wild hogs to European domestic hogs that escaped or were released. A hog in the road may be wild or may belong to someone. That is a fact I'll run down rather than assume.

Animals with an owner. Livestock and dogs usually have owners. For livestock, state law puts the duty on the "owner or manager" (S.C. Code § 47-7-110), and Abbeville County's code counts as an owner anyone who "keeps or harbors an animal" or has it in their care (§ 6-2), so a person running cattle on rented pasture can count as one.

If you were a passenger, you may have a claim against the driver's coverage, the owner's side or both. If the driver is family, that claim usually means their insurance, not them; my passenger guide explains who pays a passenger. If a driver who swerved for the animal hit you, that driver's coverage may be in the picture too; I explain who pays below.

Not sure whose animal it was? That is where I'll start. Call or text (864) 777-1000.

When Livestock Get Out of the Fence: The Owner's Duty

What usually has to be shown: the owner or manager was careless

A claim over livestock loose on a public road generally needs evidence that the owner, or the person managing the animal, was careless, and evidence about the fence or an earlier escape can supply it. Looking for that evidence is my job, not yours. State law makes it unlawful for an owner or manager "wilfully or negligently" to let a domestic animal run at large off land they own, lease, occupy or control (S.C. Code § 47-7-110).

The South Carolina Supreme Court has said the statute "does not impose an absolute duty to prevent the escape of livestock," and that the mere presence of unattended animals on a highway "is insufficient" to show a violation (1968, 251 S.C. 171). The South Carolina Court of Appeals has held that "negligence, not strict liability, is the appropriate standard" when livestock wander into a highway (2010, Opinion No. 4755). A dog that bites or attacks is different, as I explain below.

The proof: the fence, the gate and earlier escapes

The evidence starts at the fence line: where the animal got out, the gate and whether it was latched, a gap or a washout, earlier escapes and calls to animal services, neighbors who remember, and who managed the pasture if the land was leased. I'll look at all of it and, with your OK, talk to the neighbors.

The South Carolina Supreme Court has held that a jury could weigh evidence that an owner "negligently failed to maintain a reasonably adequate pasture fence," and that an employee's knowledge of an animal's inclination to escape can count against the owner (1982, 277 S.C. 310). An earlier escape can matter even if a different animal got out: "There is no requirement that the prior incident involve the same animal" (Court of Appeals, 1990, 300 S.C. 358).

If the animal came off a trailer instead, the claim may run toward whoever was hauling it; my truck page explains when the federal trucking rules reach a farm truck. A fence can be mended and a gate latched, so tell me early where the animal came from. Call or text (864) 777-1000.

Local rules in Abbeville County: no livestock loose on the roads

The county, the City of Abbeville and Due West each have a rule against livestock running at large:

  • Abbeville County's code bars a livestock owner or any "other person with custody and control" from letting livestock run at large, "including streets, rights-of-way and highways of the county" (§ 6-14(a)).
  • The City of Abbeville's code bars horses, mules, cattle, hogs, goats and other stock from running at large in the city (§ 4-1).
  • Due West's town code says, "No livestock shall be permitted to run at large" (§ 4-66(b)).

Dogs That Run at Cars, Motorcycles and Bicycles

For a dog that bites or attacks, South Carolina law is stricter than for cattle on the road. The dog statute makes the owner or keeper liable when a person is "bitten or otherwise attacked" in a public place (S.C. Code § 47-3-110), with exceptions such as provocation, and the South Carolina Supreme Court has called that "a strict liability approach" (2009, Opinion No. 26596). If a dog ran at your car, motorcycle or bicycle and you crashed without any contact, the statute does not say whether that counts as "otherwise attacked." It may count, and the county's rules may also matter. My dog-bite page covers the defenses and the insurance. If you were on a motorcycle, see my motorcycle accident page.

If you hit a dog that was loose in the road, I'll trace how it got out. Earlier complaints can matter. Abbeville County's code makes it a public nuisance to keep an animal that "repeatedly chases, accosts, harasses, attacks or interferes with the use of public right-of-way by pedestrians, bicyclists, or motorists" (§ 6-6(6)). Outside city and town limits, the county's code bars dogs from running at large on the roads (§ 6-5(a)). Inside the city, the City of Abbeville's code declares "dogs molesting passersby, passing vehicles or other pet animals" a nuisance (§ 4-53(a)). I'll ask animal services and the county for any record of earlier calls about the dog.

What to Do When an Animal Was in the Road

  1. Get safe and call 911. The general steps after any wreck are in my Abbeville County crash guide.
  2. Photograph the animal, if it is safe to. Under the county's code, dead animals on roadways are disposed of by "the appropriate local, county or state agency" (§ 6-11), so your photos may be the only record of the animal itself. Also photograph the road, the fence line, the gate, any gap, any trailer, and any collar, tag or brand.
  3. Don't try to herd or move livestock yourself; leave that to the officer or animal services. The county's code gives them the right to take up loose livestock (§ 6-14(b)).
  4. Ask who owns it, and write down who answers: the officer, a neighbor, someone who comes for the animal.
  5. Make sure the report names the animal. The state's crash report form has one code for a deer and one for all other animals, so ask the officer to write down what it was: a cow, a horse, a dog.
  6. Know the county's numbers. The county's E-911 page lists (864) 366-8451 as its "Non-Emergency Dispatch Line" and (864) 366-6639 for "Animal Shelter & Control."
  7. Don't give the owner's insurer a recorded statement, and don't argue about fault. Call or text (864) 777-1000 first. My guide covers what to say when an insurer calls.
  8. Keep every medical appointment. A gap in treatment can weaken a claim.

Who Pays: The Owner's Side, the Other Driver and Your Own Policy

The owner's side. If the owner is a neighbor, suing may be the last thing you want. When the owner, or the person managing the animal, was careless, the claim generally runs against them, but in practice that usually means their liability insurance, if they have coverage that applies. Your own policy may also pay.

The driver who swerved. A driver who swerved for the animal and hit you may argue the animal created a sudden emergency. That argument generally does not end your claim by itself: the South Carolina Court of Appeals has said the doctrine "does not bar a plaintiff's claim as a matter of law" (2006, Opinion No. 4140). Still, a driver who did not cause the emergency is generally judged by whether they reacted as a sensible person might. If that driver was careless and had no insurance, your own uninsured motorist coverage may stand in.

Your own driving. Generally, hitting a cow does not by itself make you the careless one. In 1955 the South Carolina Supreme Court relied on jury instructions saying a driver who hit and killed a cow is not presumed negligent, and that the test is due care "under the circumstances of the particular case" (227 S.C. 157). The owner's insurer can still argue speed: state law bars driving "at a speed greater than is reasonable and prudent under the conditions" (S.C. Code § 56-5-1520(A)). If fault is shared, South Carolina's 51 percent rule generally decides what you can recover.

The clock. You generally have three years to sue for an injury (S.C. Code § 15-3-530(5)), and a claim against a government body can mean a shorter clock; see the deadlines that run shorter.

A death. If someone you love was killed, my wrongful death page explains who brings the claim, and the three-year clock for a death claim generally runs from the date of death (§ 15-3-530(6)).

Why I Drive to Abbeville, and Where I'll Meet You

Abbeville is about 55 miles from 100 Williams St in Greenville, and after a wreck, that drive should be mine, not yours. You pick the place: your home in Abbeville, Calhoun Falls, Due West, Donalds or Lowndesville, a porch out in the county, or a hospital room. Keep any photos of the animal and the fence line handy; I'll go over them with you. I come to you myself, and after that I'll keep in touch by phone and text, on a schedule that respects farm hours and shift work. You don't have to drive to Greenville to sign up, and if your case is filed in Abbeville County, I drive to Court Square. My Abbeville page explains where an Abbeville County case is filed. Call or text (864) 777-1000.

"Every client gets my personal cell number. Call or text me directly — you'll never chase a case manager."

Clients hear back from me the same day — and for emergencies, anytime.

— Thomas Spiro Conits

Questions

Animal-in-the-Road Accident FAQs for Abbeville County

I hit a cow on an Abbeville County road. Can I make a claim against the farmer?

Possibly. South Carolina generally treats it as a fault claim, not automatic liability (S.C. Code § 47-7-110), so the cow being on the road is not enough by itself. The claim generally turns on evidence of how it got out, such as the fence, the gate and earlier escapes. I'll dig for that evidence.

A dog ran out at my motorcycle and I went down. Is that a dog-bite case?

It might be. South Carolina's dog statute reaches a person "bitten or otherwise attacked," and it does not say whether a chase without contact counts. I'll look at how the dog came at you, the local rules against dogs loose on the road, and any earlier complaints about the dog.

I was a passenger in a car that hit a loose cow. Who pays me?

The driver's liability coverage may pay if the driver was careless, and the owner's side may pay if the owner, or whoever managed the cow, was careless. I'll track down every policy that may apply.

Nobody knows whose cow it was. Now what?

Ask the officer to write down what the animal was. I'll ask animal services and, with your OK, the neighbors whose it is. The county can take up loose livestock and recover its costs from the owner (Abbeville County Code § 6-14(b)), so its records may lead to the owner, and I'll follow that trail.

I hit a deer. Do I have a case against anyone?

Usually not. A wild deer generally leaves no one else to claim against. Your own policy may still pay, and another driver's swerve or a road defect can change the answer.

Wrecked over an animal in the road? I'll come to you in Abbeville County.

We can meet at your home, in the hospital, or wherever you're comfortable, across Greenville and the surrounding counties. You can also see me at 100 Williams St in Greenville by appointment, or call me and I'll set up a FaceTime or WhatsApp video chat.

— Thomas Spiro Conits

An animal in the road in Abbeville County? Talk to Tom — free

Free consultation. No fee unless we win. If getting to an office is hard right now, Tom will come to you.

100 Williams St, Greenville, SC 29601 (by appointment) · (864) 777-1000